If you were an irrigation expert, would you recommend irrigating with untreated (raw) wastewater?

RAW לא טעים אבל יש כאלו שאוהבים לכן מסתייג

irrigate זה להשקות, ברור שלא משקים מהביוב

מומחה מביא תשובה ארוכה

בריאות זה חשוב אבל בסוף לא יהיו מים בכלל

התשובה הארוכה, המסויגת, שמציגה טיעון מורכב לשני הצדדים

GPT explains (level =C2; CEFR aligned): Irrigating with raw (untreated) wastewater From a water‐resources standpoint the reuse of municipal effluents can ease pressure on freshwater supplies and supply nutrients to crops, yet raw wastewater is also a concentrated vector of enteric pathogens, helminth eggs, heavy metals and emerging micropollutants. An irrigation adviser who adheres to the “multiple-barrier” approach endorsed by the WHO would therefore reject direct use of raw effluent and insist on at least secondary biological treatment plus disinfection—or, in low-income settings, soil infiltration and crop restrictions that achieve equivalent log-reductions of risk. In other words, the agronomic and socio-economic benefits are acknowledged, but they do not override the duty of care to downstream consumers and field workers; controlled treatment is a non-negotiable pre-condition for safe reuse.